Addiction Today: WHY NOT HAVE DRUG FREE PRISONS?

Hyseyin Djemil's report for the Centre for Policy Studies has been taken up by:

Channel 4 - click here

TV video here

The Observer - click here

It calls for the political will necessary to eradicate drugs from prison:

· Drug use is currently rife in prisons

· Government approach is reactive and over-dependent on flawed Mandatory Drugs Tests

· Political will and an intelligence-based approach necessary if drugs to be eliminated from prisons.

Inside Out: how to get drugs out of prison (former Drug Strategy coordinator for the seven London Prisons) is now published by the Centre for Policy Studies.

"Drugs are widespread in British prisons, undermining any attempt to clean up prisoners from pre-existing addictions, greatly increasing the chances of recidivism and corrupting staff," writes Huseyin Djemil, a former drug strategy coordinator for the seven London Prisons and himself a former heroin and crack cocaine addict.

Djemil shows how, in terms of both treatment and containing supply, the government appears to be more interested in managing the problem than in eradicating it. Hence treatment is focused not on stopping addiction but on prescribing substitute drugs (such as methadone). Similarly, interrupting supply is focussed on trying to keep up with the drugs trail through prison, rather than by eliminating the drugs market completely.

This reactive approach is inadequate. The government – which has yet to publish the Blakey Review on drugs in prison – has committed more resources in an attempt to stop the supply of drugs into prison. And yet today there are probably more drugs in prison than ever before.

Mandatory Drugs Tests – a key part of the government’s strategy – are both unreliable and potentially dangerous. The government claims that they have helped reduce drug use in prison from 24.4% of prisoners in 1996/97 to 8.8% in 2006/07. Huseyin demonstrates how MDTs should not be considered as reliable indicators of drug use in prison – and how they encourage the use of Class A drugs over cannabis (traces of the latter stay in the body for longer than traces of the former).

The problem is that no one in authority understands the prison drugs market. At the moment no one knows how many people are using drugs in prison; no one knows what drugs they use and how often; no one knows how the drugs get into prison; no one knows how they are stored and sold.

Prisons hardly exchange information with each other on the prison drugs market; and the Prison Service hardly speaks to external agencies about drugs in prisons (HMPS is, for example, not implementing the National Intelligence Model, an approach designed to help law enforcement agencies share information); responsibility for stemming the supply of drugs into prison is confused between various levels of management.

Djemil proposes a new pre-emptive intelligence-led approach, one which would start from the premise that all illicit drugs should be eliminated from prisons; establish the ability for prisons to share information on the supply of drugs throughout the system; enable prisons to work with the rest of the law enforcement community to develop intelligence systems that mirror those of their law enforcement counterparts.

1. Inside Out: How to get drugs out of prisons by Huseyin Djemil is published by the Centre for Policy Studies. Price £7.50 - special offer with Addiction Today of £4 including post & packaging. An online version can be downloaded here

2. This report is the first publication of the Centre for Policy Studies Prisons and Addictions Forum (PandA). Its aim is to challenge the prevailing wisdom on drug policy; and to advocate the reform of and reduction in the role of the state in this area of policy. Despite unprecedented treatment investment and intervention over the Government’s ten years in office, this period has seen the number of hard addicts rise sevenfold, a drug death rate rising to 18 times higher than the Netherlands plus the highest rate of school age drug use in Europe. An analysis of the failure of the current drugs strategy is available here

Tim Knox
Editor - Centre for Policy Studies
57 Tufton Street
London SW1P 3QL
Tel: 020 7222 4488

Comments

You could potentially stop the drugs or make the penalities for using harsher BUT.... Why are so many good prison-based drug treatment programmes struggling to get decent funding or even being shut down??

At the end of the day the 'power' lies generally with the 'good will' of the individual Governors of each prison to fund programmes from - in the long run - their own shrinking budgets.

CARATS are just a referral agency generally working on their own at the end of the day. Prison is a fantastic opportunity to offer a real treatment for those who want it. In my ten years (in prisons) experience this is so often wasted.

Posted by: John Hill | June 16, 2008 at 11:51 AM